top of page

The only hope to save the American Dream for countless small business owners and their employees is by the political courage and moral values of DSA lawmakers. The Democratic and Republican lawmakers lack the political will, courage, and principles to stand up to special interests who are protecting the destructive real estate oligarchy economy. 

 

This is the last part of our 3 part series*exposing the city’s economic policy corruption of the lobby controlled City Hall. It also details the discrimination against all business owners by a lobby’s collusion with the Democratic leadership for over a decade to rig the system to deny economic justice and rights needed by every business owner when their leases expire. Rights needed to level the playing field for the owners in order to give them a real fighting chance to negotiate fair lease terms. Fairness, that would allow them to remain open, protect the jobs of their workers, to be able to make a reasonable profit; so that they may plan for potential growth and job creation, so that they may keep their American Dream alive.

​

* https://www.savenycjobs.com/rebny-cons-dsa-to-be-a-lobby

https://www.savenycjobs.com/dsa-set-up-for-fall

​

It is a sad, disgraceful, and embarrassing story of lawmakers who had to make a choice between serving special interests by abandoning their progressive values and ethics or being an honest progressive voice serving the welfare of their merchants, their workers and the will of the people. The corruption centers around who controls the vital commercial lease renewal process.  The perversion of democracy focuses on the history of two bills, Small Business Jobs Survival Act, Jobs Survival Act and Commercial Rent Stabilization Act, rightfully called REBNY’s Bill. Parts I and II show undeniably that the majority of lawmakers threw their progressive values and morality under the bus along with their business owners and their worker’s future to serve their own and the real estate lobby’s interests.

​

The level of moral reprehensible corruption of our government by a lobby is tied to the history of these two bills. The true state of health of the backbone of our economy is also entangled by these two bills. The willingness and commitment by lawmakers to successfully find real solutions to end three crises: small business rent crisis, empty store blight and affordability crises are intertwined with these two bills. The respect and appreciation of their sacrifices to our economy and the character and spirit of a neighborhood derived from small business owners are directly linked to these two bills. Also, the willingness of lawmakers to protect their merchant’s and workers’ American Dream depend upon these two bills.  Most importantly, the two bills determined the type of economic policy that NYC has or will have, either continuing a real estate oligarchy economy or beginning a true entrepreneur driven economy.

​

The theme of our first two part OP EDs highlighted a new strategy by the real estate lobby, REBNY, that controlled the outcome of these two bills at City Hall. Through their many elected loyalists, who they helped put into office and into powerful political positions, and the many lobby’s shills pretending to speak for small business owners, REBNY has fully controlled both the fate of the bill they inspired, REBNY’s Bill, as well as the tenant’s Jobs Survival Act.

​

As we detailed in parts I and II, the original REBNY’s Bill was a cleverly disguised status quo bill that was anti-small business, anti-jobs, and especially anti-immigrant families and would not save a single business owner or job, unless the landlord wanted too. Therefore, the strategy was simple for REBNY, never hold any public hearings where their bill would be challenged and exposed as being nothing but a status quo bill keeping the landlords in full control of the critical, and highly profitable, commercial lease renewal process. For 5 ½ years since REBNY’s Bill was touted by lobby loyal lawmakers and shills, led by Brad Lander,* and the property owner controlled BIDS* and developer/fat cats friendly Chambers, as the legislation to save small business owners when their leases expired, no effort was ever made to move the bill to a vote, even with 28 sponsors! Shamefully, even during the Covid Crisis! In fact, every effort was made by City Hall to hide the existence of both bills. The vast majority of the city’s 195K plus business owners never heard of either bill.

​

*https://www.savenycjobs.com/brad-lander-leads-rigging

​

How could a lobby get away for over a decade with hijacking democracy with their REBNY’s Bill while three purposely unchecked citywide crises were growing worse?  Crises that REBNY’s landlord members created and that the only real solution, the Jobs Survival Act, that would end all three, was prevented from being voted on four times, even with strong majority sponsors. The answer is simple, REBNY has controlled the small business narrative of the true state of health of business owners and the “root cause” of long established successful business owners being forced to close due only to not having any rights to the commercial lease renewal process.

The real estate lobby’s elected loyalists and many pro real estate shills have put on disinformation political theater to cover up the negative consequences to business owners, their workers and to society of their destructive real estate oligarchy economy. The truth is that every business owner in NYC when their leases expire has a gun to their heads under the grossly one sided “take it or leave” landlord controlled lease renewal process. Their futures, as well as their worker’s futures were at the mercy of their landlords.

​

In parts I and II we made the case that a powerful real estate lobby, REBNY, was taking a major gamble with a new scheme to never have landlords regulated in the commercial lease renewal process. The lobby used lobby friendly loyalists to deceive targeted DSA lawmakers into championing legislation influenced by the lobby, their updated, but still status quo REBNY’s Bill. For the first time in over a decade REBNY was putting their bill into the hands of DSA lawmakers and shifting it out of the control and responsibility of the City Council. The responsibility and control of REBNY’s Bill was now in the hands of DSA lawmakers in Albany. REBNY’s red hot potato was heading north! What did REBNY know about DSA lawmakers to give them confidence that their Machiavellian scheme would succeed?

​

REBNY knew that none of DSA lawmakers would do serious research of the history of REBNY’s Bill, including who was behind its creation and why. Also, that none would question if there was a better solution to protect the investment of small business owners and the jobs of their workers. None would ask if any part of the bill was in conflict with the ideals of DSA. As the proclaimed champions and stewards of working families’ welfare, rights and justice none would ask the business owners or workers themselves what they needed for job security and job opportunity.

​

Instead, REBNY sent their most trusted loyalist to use their friendships and reputations to deceive DSA lawmakers into trusting them wholeheartedly. This deception had to work otherwise REBNY’s scheme would have to be abandoned. But shamefully, so far it has worked perfectly.

​

REBNY knew that their bill was written for landlords and not for business tenant’s rights. It was written solely to keep the status quo for landlords in the highly profitable and grossly unfair commercial lease renewal process. They also knew that their successful collusion with lawmakers to rig the system to prevent a vote (4 times) of the Jobs Survival Act would result in plotting to continue to ignore three growing crises caused by their real estate oligarchy economy. Despicably, they knew that REBNY’s Bill would also make all three crises much worse!  If the full truth of the discrimination against business owners caused by corrupt lawmakers was ever exposed, REBNY’s Bill would be the most politically toxic bill in Council History. Support for this toxic bill was reprehensible and indefensible for any lawmaker with true empathy for the dire plight of business owners when their leases expired and they had no real rights. Also, unacceptable for those who had a moral obligation to protect their merchant’s life’s investment and their worker’s jobs!

​

PART III

How DSA lawmakers can backfire REBNY’s sinister scheme!

REBNY, along with other special interests, now fear the potential success of DSA candidates in NYC elections. For most suave political professionals, it is unimaginable to believe that only a DSA lawmaker with the courage and political will to stand up to REBNY can wreck REBNY’s game plan. That the courage of one single DSA lawmaker can break the chains of decades of involuntary servitude of business owners and their workers to landlords. Even more inconceivable is believing that only a DSA lawmaker has the power to end three citywide crises! Yet, all true!

Incredible to believe that the only real pathway to restore democracy at City Hall and restore the American Dream for countless business owners and their workers is through DSA lawmakers who have not been duped into throwing away their progressive values and DSA ethics. Duped by lawmakers they respect and trust, but who have hidden their true loyalty to a lobby. 

​

The starting point for DSA lawmakers to successfully backfire REBNY’s scheme is to open their minds to new ideas and open their eyes to the reality of the outcome of Big real estate's control of our economy and stranglehold on democracy at City Hall. The shameful reality in the Council is that every Council Member had a choice to make as the voice for their merchants and workers. Every Council Member is responsible for the stability of their local economy, the environment to promote prosperity for their business owners, the promotion of the potential for growth and job creation, finding a real solution to the sky high rent crisis, ending the empty store blight crisis with a real solution and restoring the American Dream for many merchants and their workers.

​

Directly or indirectly every Council Member has chosen to abdicate their responsibilities for the backbone of their local economy to a lobby. For their own self interests, all have either been complicit to, or willingly and eagerly joined in, the collusion of the real estate lobby with the Democratic leadership to deny economic justice to small business owners and their workers.  All have played willful ignorance to the three crises caused by our city’s real estate oligarchy economy.

​

Therefore, DSA lawmakers should understand that NO Democratic lawmaker will challenge REBNY’s political power and undue influence in the Council. Especially its Democratic leadership! If Council Members have not acted by now, they will never act and risk exposing their own roles of none action in a time of three crises and blatant open corruption at City Hall. The only real lifeline to save small business owners and the jobs of their workers when a lease expires can only come from DSA lawmakers not controlled by REBNY.  

​

The good news for DSA lawmakers that are true progressives is that a real solution already exists to the small business crisis caused by sky high rents. Also, a solution to the empty store blight crisis resulting from the government purposely ignoring the small business rent crisis. As well as a solution to begin to seriously address the catalyst of the affordability crisis.

​

That real solution is still the Jobs Survival Act, a bill created by small business advocates that gives real rights to all business owners when their leases expire. Rights needed to level the playing field for owners to have a real fighting chance to negotiate fair lease terms that allow them to remain open while making a reasonable profit. DSA lawmakers should know that even though the collusion by Democratic leadership with a lobby and the complicity of Council Members that prevented a vote on the Jobs Survival Act four times, that a vote today could not be stopped with its reintroduction into the Council.

​

Why our claim that REBNY and their loyalists cannot prevent a vote for the fifth time on the Jobs Survival Act, can be shown by then Council Member John Liu’s statement before a June 2009 emergency hearing on the Jobs Survival Act. In June 2009 after the officials of Small Business Services and Economic Development testified, Councilman John Liu exposed both agencies for whom they really serve, Big real estate.

 

COUNCIL MEMBER LIU: Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Commissioners, the reason I was asking you about illegal cash money (31% from a survey demanded by landlords targeting immigrant owners) before was just to highlight a clear example of a problem that does exist and yet, the administration does not have any kind of handle on it. The reason I say that is because every time we have a hearing with EDC or with Small Business Services, there is always talk about all these great programs that are out there to help small businesses. I've always said not to tell me to go back to my constituents with these programs because they don’t really think very much of these programs. They don’t. I think we'll hear testimony to that effect. So as much as your two departments and agencies can say that you have all these great programs to assist small businesses, the small businesses aren't buying it. They're not buying it because they're not being asked what they need help with.. So I would ask you to really consider this legislation and think of it as a real way to help small businesses. Now nobody is suggesting that the city start regulating the rents. That's not what the bill (Jobs Survival Act) says..we are asking only to assisting them so they have a little bit more leverage because right now they're totally dependent upon the landlord of the building that they have spent years building up their small business.”

​

One word has allowed REBNY and their Council cronies to successfully continue their rigging of the system to keep the status quo landlord controlled commercial lease renewal process. That word is “choice”! As Councilman Liu exposed, the city’s agencies mandated to be a voice for small business owners, as well as the lobby’s cronies, have refused to allow the VICTIMS of a failed destructive process to have a choice in deciding legislation they need to protect their investment and the jobs of their workers. In fact, disingenuous and cowardly lawmakers have all conspired to keep their own merchants, workers, and the public in the dark of this real lifeline to save small business owners and the jobs of their workers.

​

For over a decade the real estate lobby has built a huge network of shills to cover up both the three crises caused by a real estate oligarchy economy and cover up the only real solution to end all three.  For DSA lawmakers to know the truth of which legislation is best to stop the closing of long established successful business owners when their leases expire and to save jobs, they first must ignore the flood of real estate propaganda and Machiavellian schemes from City Hall and also coming from the many lobby’s shills. Too shut out the over decade long lobby orchestrated political theater from City Hall of useless bills, worthless initiatives, fake studies, contrived distractions and outright lies, such as the BIG LIE that the real problems of small business owners are “to many fines and to many regulations,” total nonsense! 

​

DSA lawmakers must also realize that the network of lobby shills have all greatly profited from continuing a real estate oligarchy economy. These lobby shills have shown up and dominate at every hearing, forum, and conferences etc., testifying to stop any vote on the Jobs Survival Act, while supporting REBNY’s Bill.  If small business issues are the topic, REBNY’s shills always control the narrative through: property owner controlled BIDS,* developer friendly Chambers, real estate controlled SBS and EDC, pro real estate CB members, fake lobby inspired coalitions like United for Small Business NYC, Small Business United, and dozens of REBNY elected loyalists led by Brad Lander, Gail Brewer, Carolina Rivera, Diana Ayala, and Brad Hoylman, just to name a few. Who should a DSA lawmaker believe? Believe the victims of the greatest transfer of wealth from hard working entrepreneurs to landlords, believe your own merchants and their workers.

*https://www.savenycjobs.com/bids-final-part-x

​

Why would any lone DSA lawmaker believe that they could succeed in standing up to the most powerful city lobby in America who controls the Democratic leadership at City Hall, and gain a vote on the Jobs Survival Act, when after four decades others failed?  

​

The pathway to succeed was open by two words: “gamble and choice”. REBNY took a huge gamble moving their political toxic bill to Albany knowing it would create a negative image for DSA.  Also, knowing when the lobby's bill was made public it would produce instant anger from merchants who would feel betrayed. Anger and a negative image against DSA lawmakers and their future candidates that REBNY would use in future elections to protect and keep their cronies in power.  But what if someone did their due diligence and researched the bill’s shameful history and opened DSA lawmaker’s eyes to REBNY’s scheme?

​

The decades long battle over legislation that regulates NYC’s commercial lease renewal process started in the City Council in the mid 1980’s. For over four decades the Jobs Survival Act has had 12 hearings, 8 prime sponsors, amended 5 times, and been reintroduced in the Council countless times. It belongs only in the City Council to decide the fate of NYC business owners and their workers when their leases expire. Why should lawmakers from Buffalo, Watertown, or Syracuse be deciding the futures of 195K plus NYC business owners and millions of their employees? Unwise!  DSA lawmakers should send REBNY’s hot potato back to where it belongs, the neighborhoods of NYC.

​

The other word needed for successfully passing the Jobs Survival Act into law is choice. John Liu was right in stating that business owners would never buy any legislation that they have no voice in. During this election cycle polls are being given out almost daily. No poll ever showed a 100% on an issue. Yet, if merchants were finally told the truth and given the choice between keeping the status quo when their leases expired or given the right to renew 10 year leases, equal rights to negotiate the new terms and an arbitration process based upon “case by case” guidelines that ended all landlord abuses, ending even tenants being forced to pay the landlord's property taxes, and depending upon the neighborhood could even lower the rents, 100% would choose the Jobs Survival Act.

​

If that poll prediction seems unlikely this is another 100% poll. If NYC business owners were asked, “would you support legislation that had the government determine your annual rent rate increase? Legislation where the rents can only go up and never down from the decades long insane increases! Also, the same rent rates are for every business owner regardless of size or location of the business. A small shoe repair shop in the Bronx would pay the same rent increase as an international Wall Street Firm. Also, legislation that has no independent arbitration process, and where besides the length of lease and the rent rate increase, the business owners have no rights or say in the other lease terms.” 100% NO WAY! No business owner would trust the government to determine any terms of the critical lease renewal. The profits of business owners must matter in the commercial lease renewal process or eventually all business owners will be in jeopardy of closing! Under NYC’s real estate oligarchy economy only the profits of landlords matter!

​

What this all means is simple, REBNY put a live political grenade, their bill, into the hands of DSA lawmakers and will have their handpicked candidates pull the pins in future elections.

​

For those knowing the political power of special interests at City Hall and doubting our predictions as foolish, we will give you our most extreme prediction. The Jobs Survival Act can be amended to be the most economic/social act legislation in America! Amended to promote DSA social commitments to working families but also be taxpayer friendly.  DSA lawmakers must open their minds to be aware that there is a direct connection, a natural partnership, between the success of their social goals and programs and the state of health of the backbone of local economies. If an economy is stable and growing to produce good paying working family jobs then there will be less demand for social programs that provide a safety net for working families. Also, supporting pro small business legislation will keep the more successful businesses in business and offer the potential for more growth and more job creation.

 

DSA must never be confused into believing that our city’s real estate oligarchy economy is true Capitalism. Nothing could be further from the truth, because it is the exact opposite of Capitalism. The empty storefronts on every main block where once thriving businesses were are proof of this reality.   

​

In NYC’s lobby controlled City Hall, economy only means BIG BUSINESS! But a major revenue collector for the city’s budget are its over 195K business owners and their over 2 million workers. Big business, especially in real estate, hate to pay taxes and use their friends in government to reduce their taxes. The real estate oligarchy economy, which has been the job destroyers is protected and promoted by City Hall, while small business owners, which are the job creators are discriminated against. DSA lawmakers must get on the side of the oppressed and exploited small business owners and their workers and not be lobbyists for a real estate oligarchy economy.

​

A seemingly wild, but possible prediction is if DSA lawmakers amend the Jobs Survival Act to make it impact the homeless, hard to employ, a jobs training program for the less skilled, less educated or disabled and offer a lower cost for food for those in need then it would become the MOST PROGRESSIVE LEGISLATION IN THE NATION. It would be copied by many large and small cities nationwide. Imagine the DSA brand being praised and copied for its decency, humanity, sound economics and being taxpayer friendly. Imagine DSA lawmakers successfully passing legislation that the Democrats and Republicans willfully refused to do for over a decade. Shamefully true that the city’s three uncheck crises were a result of a lobby controlled City Hall. Both Republicans and Democrats  willfully refused because they were protecting a destructive real estate oligarchy economy and protecting their own political careers. Imagine further that only the DSA lawmakers made a priority to find a true solution to end three crises. Hopefully for all New Yorkers, DSA lawmakers, unlike Democrats and Republicans, refuse to accept as the new norm for main street where popular long established successful local businesses are forced to close and jobs lost and where the once thriving business on main street remains empty for sometimes years. DSA lawmakers refuse to accept an insane real estate driven economy in the extreme. DSA lawmakers also refused to accept playing any role in the government institutionalized discrimination against working families.

​

This scenario is not so far fetched when the truth is exposed of the betrayal of lawmakers to their own merchant’s and worker’s survival and futures. Every lawmaker in NYC fears the exposure of their role played in this reprehensible collusion with a lobby and their many shills to rig the system against small business owners. Also, they fear the question that may be asked by their constituents: “why don’t their beloved mom and pop merchants deserve rights when their leases expire to negotiate fair lease terms that would keep them in business, protect the jobs of their employees, keep the local economy stable and keep alive the character and spirit of the neighborhood?” What Council Member dares to look their merchants in the face and tell them that as their voice in government responsible for their welfare they do not want them to have the rights needed to have a fighting chance to survive or save their American Dream? None, if they want to be reelected.

​

For all business owners, their workers, and all New Yorkers who treasure their beloved mom and pop merchants, their question is simple. Are their local lawmakers on the side of the landlords or on the side of their merchants and their workers? The answer to this question is also simple and can be found in which bill their lawmaker supports: the landlord’s REBNY’s Bill or the tenant’s Jobs Survival Act.  

​

The question of who will save the American Dream for business owners and their workers is also simple. On behalf of the city’s working families, we ask, is there an honest voice who will fight for the voiceless in our real estate-controlled City Hall? Are there any DSA lawmakers with the political will and courage to stand up to REBNY and the Democratic leadership they control? Are DSA lawmakers with an open mind willing to make it a priority of supporting legislation to restore to business owner’s and their workers their American Dream while at the same time having social programs that serve the working families? Well, are they? Talk is cheap, especially disingenuous political rhetoric, how about real actions to prevent an economic catastrophe coming soon to NYC caused by continuing to support a destructive real estate oligarchy economy. 

bottom of page